Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn birthcontrol. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng
Hiển thị các bài đăng có nhãn birthcontrol. Hiển thị tất cả bài đăng

Thứ Tư, 15 tháng 2, 2012

Bishops plan aggressive expansion of birth-control battle

(Reuters) - Catholic bishops, energized by a battle over contraception funding, are planning an aggressive campaign to rally Americans against a long list of government measures which they say intrude on religious liberty.

The U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops plans to work with other religious groups, including evangelical Christians, on an election-year public relations campaign that may include TV and radio ads, social media marketing and a push for pastors and priests to raise the subject from the pulpit.

"We want to make it something that will get peoples' attention," said Bishop William Lori of Bridgeport, Conn.

The bishops spent the past few weeks pressing President Barack Obama to exempt religious employers from a federal mandate that all health insurance plans offer free birth control.

Obama agreed to modify the mandate a bit, so that religious employers wouldn't have to pay for contraceptive coverage directly. That satisfied some Catholic groups, but the bishops were not mollified. They want the mandate repealed altogether.

And now, they are aiming higher still, lobbying Congress to enact a law that would let any employer opt out of covering any medical treatment he disagreed with as a matter of his personal faith.

So, for instance, a pizzeria owner who objected to childhood vaccinations on religious grounds would be able to request an insurance plan that did not cover them, in effect overriding a federal requirement that vaccinations be provided free with any health-insurance plan.

Leaving coverage decisions up to each employers' conscience might create chaos in the marketplace, "but chaos is sometimes the price you pay for freedom," said Richard Land, the president of the Southern Baptist Convention's Ethics & Religious Liberty Commission, who is backing the bishops whole-heartedly.

Democrats, who control the Senate, are likely to block any bill with such broad opt-out provisions.

But supporters, including prominent Republicans, say they will keep pushing for the change, which fits into a wider theme of defending individual freedoms against government intrusion which is expected to play prominently in the November election.

MESSAGE FROM THE PULPIT

Along with the Southern Baptist Convention, the National Association of Evangelicals stands ready to contribute money and manpower to the bishops' campaign, said Galen Carey, an association vice president.

The group is also considering the unprecedented step of asking pastors of every evangelical denomination across the country to read their congregations an open letter protesting the contraception mandate as an assault on religious liberty.

Liberal groups are already launching counter-attacks.

This week, NARAL Pro-Choice America, which works to keep abortion legal and expand contraceptive access, spent $250,000 to air radio ads in four swing states that will be crucial to the presidential election -- Colorado, Florida, Virginia and Wisconsin.

The ads urge support for Obama and his effort to ensure that "women of all faiths, no matter where they work," can get free birth control with their health insurance.

More than 30 organizations supporting Obama teamed up to create the Coalition to Protect Women's Health Care, which has started an online petition and plans further action.

The coalition includes two unions that represent millions of workers and have well-honed networks for getting out political messages, the Service Employees International Union and the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees.

Obama's supporters say the president went far enough to accommodate religious institutions when he announced last week that they wouldn't have to pay for free birth control as part of their insurance plans; he said instead their insurers would be required to pick up the costs.

The bishops denounced this as a gimmick that doesn't solve anything, especially for the many religious hospitals and schools that self-insure their employees.

"Reasonable people should be able to work through the details of this and find common ground," said John Gehring, Catholic outreach coordinator for the liberal group Faith in Public Life. "But election-year politics doesn't make for cool heads."

BATTLE FOR RELIGIOUS FREEDOM

The Conference of Catholic Bishops began preparing months ago for a battle royale over religious freedom. Last fall, the conference bulked up its staff, hiring a lawyer who had devoted his career to religious liberty cases and a lobbyist to press the cause in Washington. The group also created a special committee on religious liberty, chaired by Bishop Lori.

In a September letter announcing the committee, Archbishop Timothy Dolan declared that religious freedom "is now increasingly and in unprecedented ways under assault in America." He and other officials offer many examples of that perceived assault.

On the federal level, the Obama administration has cancelled or threatened to cancel contracts awarded to Catholic charities for work to prevent HIV and to help victims of sex trafficking. The administration says the charities have to provide services such as condoms, emergency contraception and abortion referrals to maintain the contracts; the charities protest that such conditions violate their religious faith.

Several states, meanwhile, have required adoption agencies that receive public funds to treat same-sex couples on par with any other prospective foster or adoptive parent. Catholic Charities object, saying the church doesn't sanction gay and lesbian relationships. Rather than comply with the laws, bishops in Illinois, Massachusetts and Washington D.C. have shut down Catholic adoption agencies.

The bishops portray this as an out-and-out war on free exercise of religion.

But secular and liberal groups say no one's assailing the freedom to worship, to proselytize -- or even to perform social services, such as placing needy children in loving homes, according to religious precepts.

It is only when a religious institution accepts taxpayer money to do such work that religious freedom must take a back seat to secular laws, said Marci Hamilton, a constitutional scholar at Cardozo School of Law.

Courts nationwide have repeatedly ruled that religious groups must follow the same rules as everyone else when holding a government contract, Hamilton said. Any institution that can't in good faith follow those rules shouldn't apply for public funding, she said.

GUARDING CONTRACEPTION

With regard to contraceptive care, courts in New York and California have upheld state laws -- similar to the federal mandate -- that insurance plans, including those sponsored by religious employers, must cover birth control if they cover other prescription drugs.

It is unclear whether such nuances will filter into the public debate over religious freedom and contraceptive coverage.

Both sides say they believe public opinion is firmly in their corner -- and they're determined to keep it that way with a steady drumbeat of snappy soundbites.

More than 100 university professors and religious leaders from different faiths released a letter of protest against the administration Tuesday that was headlined with a single word: "Unacceptable." The letter called the Obama administration "morally obtuse" and blasted the contraceptive coverage mandate as "a grave violation of religious freedom."

On the other side, the American Civil Liberties Union held a press conference to accuse the bishops of playing politics in the name of faith. The bishops are promoting "a distorted view of religious liberty -- one that has no basis in law or the Constitution," said Daniel Mach, director of the ACLU Program on Freedom of Religion and Belief.

(Reporting By Stephanie Simon in Denver,; additional reporting by Thomas Ferraro; Editing by David Storey and Marilyn Thompson)


View the original article here

Thứ Hai, 13 tháng 2, 2012

Allies blitzed White House, calling for birth-control compromise

(Reuters) - As soon as the news hit, the deluge began.

Catholics from across the country began calling the White House within hours of the Obama administration's announcement on January 20 that religious institutions would be required to offer free birth control to employees as a health-care benefit.

But these calls weren't protests from conservative bishops or the rank-and-file in the pews. They were calls from a kitchen cabinet of informal political advisers that President Barack Obama had relied on for years -- allies who had worked with him on various social issues and in some cases, campaigned for him.

They had access, and they intended to use it to drive change in a policy they said they saw as a clumsy, provocative and an unnecessary infringement on religious liberty.

Among the many who called: Tim Roemer, a former Democratic congressman from Indiana; Stephen Schneck, a political scientist at the Catholic University of America; and Sister Simone Campbell, who runs a Catholic social-justice lobby in Washington.

They reached out to friends in the Obama campaign, in the office of Vice President Joe Biden, in the White House domestic policy shop and its office of faith-based initiatives, in the Department of Health and Human Services.

One even wrote a proposed speech for the president, in which Obama would admit he'd been wrong and offer a compromise.

"A daily dunning," is how Campbell described it.

UNCERTAIN FOOTING

From the start, Obama officials were receptive to calls for change, Campbell and others said. But they seemed uncertain about how to proceed, and the talks had little urgency.

People close to the White House said formulating the policy on contraceptive coverage had been a bruising fight, lasting for months last fall and into the winter, with deep divisions among senior staff - including its Catholics - about the wisdom of requiring Catholic colleges and hospitals to subsidize free birth control for their employees in the name of improving women's health care access.

The administration seemed prepared for a furious protest from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, a formidable adversary in the earlier debate over healthcare reform, people with knowledge of the internal debate said.

But officials appeared taken aback by the intensity of the pleas coming from close Obama allies, several of whom argued to anyone who would listen that the policy was not only morally wrong, but out of step with the president's values.

"This decision just seems not in keeping with the person he is," said Douglas Kmiec, a conservative legal scholar at Pepperdine University and an Obama supporter.

In their quest for a compromise, Kmiec and other allies of the president focused at first on what was dubbed the "Hawaii solution." Hawaii requires all health insurance plans to cover contraception. But it lets religious employers delete that benefit from their plans - so long as they agree to refer any worker seeking contraceptive coverage to a third party that can provide it at nominal cost.

The HAWAII SOLUTION

The Hawaii model excited several Catholic allies, who thought it would neatly solve the problem by ensuring that religious employers didn't have to pay for the birth control benefits themselves.

But as talk about a Hawaii solution intensified, Catholic bishops moved to quash it, arguing that referring women to low-cost contraception would be as immoral as distributing the drugs and devices first-hand.

"The church must have the freedom to refuse to cooperate in any way in making these 'services' available," Bishop William Lori, who heads a committee on religious liberty, wrote on the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops blog. "If we provide the means for another to act against the moral law, we ourselves become morally culpable as well."

That pronouncement came at the crest of a potent protest wave orchestrated by the bishops. Women's groups, meanwhile, had begun pushing back hard against suggestions of compromise.

Judy Waxman, a vice president of the National Women's Law Center, even said she would consider suing if the administration changed the policy in a way that required women to jump through any hoops to get their free contraception. "I see potential litigation in my future," she said before the compromise was reached.

Working frantically behind the scenes, Obama's loose-knit Catholic ally network continued to press its case. As noise on the issue grew, the allies said they began to gain traction with the White House. "As the momentum built, they realized, 'Uh oh, we've got trouble,' " said Campbell, the social-justice advocate.

Yet for days, a solution still seemed elusive. Several possible options would have required legislative approval, and given the divisions in Congress and heated election-year politics, Obama did not want to take that route, those familiar with the process said.

At the same time, said a senior Obama advisor, the president made clear he would not back down from his central point - that women employed by Catholic institutions should have the same right to free birth control, with no deductible and no co-pay, as woman employed by any other entity.

"It was hard figuring out the details of how this could work structurally," said John Gehring, who coordinates Catholic outreach for the group Faith in Public Life, a policy advocacy group generally aligned with Democratic policies.

As they struggled to find a solution, the would-be reformers found considerable support within the White House Office of Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnership, where several staff members suggested they were not happy with the president's original policy. A key point person there: Joshua DuBois, the office head, who knew many of Obama's outside allies from the 2008 campaign and who reports to close Obama confidant Valerie Jarrett.

The faith office "was pressing very hard for a reasonable tweaking of the policy," Gehring said.

Those pushing for compromise also found a friend in Vice President Joe Biden, a fellow Catholic, who had argued from the beginning that religious employers should be exempt from the contraception mandate.

"He understands the Catholic community's views on these issues and is willing to speak up for them when appropriate," said James Salt, executive director of Catholics United, a group with a history of supporting liberal causes.

But though they were getting high-placed signals that a compromise could be worked out, no details emerged. As the days wore on and the political rhetoric grew louder, some Obama allies got discouraged. "The lines in the sand are being drawn sharper and deeper, so I'm not optimistic," Schneck, the political scientist, said earlier this week.

On Friday, Schneck said he realized why he had received so little concrete information about the working compromise. The administration had been so divided in its deliberations about the rule, he said, that "they needed to work this out inside their own walls first," before floating it to key interest groups.

"This was an internecine struggle," he said.

A senior U.S. official said that many of the reports about the internal White House deliberations have been "overdramatized." Officials declined to comment further on internal discussions.

Late Thursday evening, administration officials reached out to Schneck and other involved parties to let them know an announcement was imminent. "There was a tremendous sense of relief," Gehring said.

Before unveiling his compromise Friday morning, Obama called Archbishop Timothy Dolan, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops; Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America; and Sister Carol Keehan, president of the Catholic Health Association of the United States.

Richards and Keehan welcomed the announcement. The Conference of Catholic Bishops has been more cautious, releasing a statement calling the new approach promising, but declining to endorse it fully.

The compromise allows religious employers to opt out of providing birth control coverage to employees. But in making that concession, Obama promised those employees that they could get free contraception all the same, courtesy of their health insurance providers.

Obama's Catholic allies said that approach hit all the right notes. "Very practical, very respectful, very common sense," Roemer said.

Sister Campbell wasn't so restrained: "This," she said, "is a glorious day."

(Reporting By Stephanie Simon in Denver. Additional reporting by Caren Bohan in Washington D.C.; Editing by Marilyn W. Thompson and Philip Barbara)


View the original article here

U.S. Catholic bishops oppose Obama birth-control plan

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - U.S. Catholic Church leaders said they will fight President Barack Obama's controversial birth-control insurance coverage policy despite his compromise that religious employers would not have to offer free contraceptives for workers, shifting the responsibility to insurers.

In an abrupt policy shift aimed at trying to end a growing election-year firestorm, Obama on Friday announced the compromise.

But the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops said its concerns were not addressed and cited "serious moral concerns."

In a statement issued Friday evening, the bishops said Obama's proposal "continues to involve needless government intrusion in the internal governance of religious institutions, and to threaten government coercion of religious people and groups to violate their most deeply held convictions."

"We will therefore continue - with no less vigor, no less sense of urgency - our efforts to correct this problem through the other two branches of government," the bishops said in urging Congress to take action to overturn the rule.

The regulation at the center of the controversy requires religious-affiliated groups such as charities, hospitals and universities, but not churches themselves, to provide employees with coverage for birth control as other health insurance providers must do.

Catholic Church leaders and Obama's Republican opponents previously led the fight against the rule requiring coverage for contraceptives as a violation of religious freedom, making it a potential big issue in the 2012 presidential race.

Obama's compromise sought to accommodate religious organizations, such as Catholic hospitals and universities. But the reaction from the bishops and other Catholic leaders made clear the battle would continue.

NO "CLEAR PROTECTION"

The bishops said the compromise failed to provide "clear protection" for many employers who might oppose birth control personally but not be classified as a religious institution, and thus ineligible to seek exemption from the federal mandate to provide free contraception as part of every insurance package.

Under the compromise, religious employers could opt out of providing coverage, but their workers could then ask their insurance company for that benefit, and the company would be required to provide it free of charge.

In reality, the bishops suggested, that meant the employer would still in effect be subsidizing the benefit, because the insurance company would likely pay for it out of the pool of revenues it earned from its contract with the employer.

"This, too, raises serious moral concerns," the bishops said.

Meanwhile, three religious groups will continue to pursue their legal challenges to the government's regulation, despite Obama's announcement, said Hannah Smith, a lawyer at the Beckett Fund for Religious Liberty, which represents the plaintiffs.

The lawsuits, filed by two religious colleges and a Catholic television network, said the government violated their constitutional rights to freedom of speech and religion. Two were filed last year and the third was filed last week.

The rule, initially announced on January 20, sparked an outcry not only from Catholic leaders but also from social conservatives, including Republican presidential hopefuls. It even drew opposition from several Democratic lawmakers.

Republicans have seized on the issue, seeking to put Obama on the defensive as signs of economic improvement appear to have re-energized his re-election bid.

Obama's compromise was aimed at preventing the controversy from becoming a liability for him with Catholic voters, while at the same time trying not to anger his liberal base.

"Birth control is basic healthcare and women should have access to birth control, no matter where they work," said Tait Sye, a spokesperson for Planned Parenthood.

"It should not be left up to a boss's personal beliefs whether his employees should be allowed birth control coverage," he said.

"SHELL GAME"

Michael O'Dea, the founder and executive director of Christus Medicus Foundation, a nonprofit advocacy group for religious healthcare providers, said many Catholic institutions have created their own self-insurance plans to get around state regulations requiring independent insurers to provide birth control if they cover other prescription drugs.

The compromise, he said, would require those insurance plans to cover the contraception - even if the insurers are arms of the Catholic Church.

"This compromise means nothing. It is nothing more than a shell game," O'Dea said.

Polls indicate a majority of Americans and Catholics support requiring contraception coverage.

On Saturday a group supporting expanded access to birth control released a survey showing that 57 percent of Catholic women favor the compromise set forth by Obama.

It found that 56 percent of independent Catholic voters favored the revised contraceptive coverage rule.

Among Hispanic Catholics, who could be pivotal in swing states such as New Mexico and Nevada, the poll found 59 percent supported the policy.

The survey, commissioned by the Coalition to Protect Women's Health Care and conducted on Friday night by Public Policy Polling, queried 466 Catholic voters. It had a margin of error of 4.5 percentage points.

(Additional reporting by Stephanie Simon in Denver and Terry Baynes in New York; Editing by Xavier Briand)


View the original article here

Thứ Sáu, 10 tháng 2, 2012

Allies blitzed White House, calling for birth-control compromise

(Reuters) - As soon as the news hit, the deluge began.

Catholics from across the country began calling the White House within hours of the Obama administration's announcement on January 20 that religious institutions would be required to offer free birth control to employees as a health-care benefit.

But these calls weren't protests from conservative bishops or the rank-and-file in the pews. They were calls from a kitchen cabinet of informal political advisers that President Barack Obama had relied on for years -- allies who had worked with him on various social issues and in some cases, campaigned for him.

They had access, and they intended to use it to drive change in a policy they said they saw as a clumsy, provocative and an unnecessary infringement on religious liberty.

Among the many who called: Tim Roemer, a former Democratic congressman from Indiana; Stephen Schneck, a political scientist at the Catholic University of America; and Sister Simone Campbell, who runs a Catholic social-justice lobby in Washington.

They reached out to friends in the Obama campaign, in the office of Vice President Joe Biden, in the White House domestic policy shop and its office of faith-based initiatives, in the Department of Health and Human Services.

One even wrote a proposed speech for the president, in which Obama would admit he'd been wrong and offer a compromise.

"A daily dunning," is how Campbell described it.

UNCERTAIN FOOTING

From the start, Obama officials were receptive to calls for change, Campbell and others said. But they seemed uncertain about how to proceed, and the talks had little urgency.

People close to the White House said formulating the policy on contraceptive coverage had been a bruising fight, lasting for months last fall and into the winter, with deep divisions among senior staff - including its Catholics - about the wisdom of requiring Catholic colleges and hospitals to subsidize free birth control for their employees in the name of improving women's health care access.

The administration seemed prepared for a furious protest from the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, a formidable adversary in the earlier debate over healthcare reform, people with knowledge of the internal debate said.

But officials appeared taken aback by the intensity of the pleas coming from close Obama allies, several of whom argued to anyone who would listen that the policy was not only morally wrong, but out of step with the president's values.

"This decision just seems not in keeping with the person he is," said Douglas Kmiec, a conservative legal scholar at Pepperdine University and an Obama supporter.

In their quest for a compromise, Kmiec and other allies of the president focused at first on what was dubbed the "Hawaii solution." Hawaii requires all health insurance plans to cover contraception. But it lets religious employers delete that benefit from their plans - so long as they agree to refer any worker seeking contraceptive coverage to a third party that can provide it at nominal cost.

The HAWAII SOLUTION

The Hawaii model excited several Catholic allies, who thought it would neatly solve the problem by ensuring that religious employers didn't have to pay for the birth control benefits themselves.

But as talk about a Hawaii solution intensified, Catholic bishops moved to quash it, arguing that referring women to low-cost contraception would be as immoral as distributing the drugs and devices first-hand.

"The church must have the freedom to refuse to cooperate in any way in making these 'services' available," Bishop William Lori, who heads a committee on religious liberty, wrote on the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops blog. "If we provide the means for another to act against the moral law, we ourselves become morally culpable as well."

That pronouncement came at the crest of a potent protest wave orchestrated by the bishops. Women's groups, meanwhile, had begun pushing back hard against suggestions of compromise.

Judy Waxman, a vice president of the National Women's Law Center, even said she would consider suing if the administration changed the policy in a way that required women to jump through any hoops to get their free contraception. "I see potential litigation in my future," she said before the compromise was reached.

Working frantically behind the scenes, Obama's loose-knit Catholic ally network continued to press its case. As noise on the issue grew, the allies said they began to gain traction with the White House. "As the momentum built, they realized, 'Uh oh, we've got trouble,' " said Campbell, the social-justice advocate.

Yet for days, a solution still seemed elusive. Several possible options would have required legislative approval, and given the divisions in Congress and heated election-year politics, Obama did not want to take that route, those familiar with the process said.

At the same time, said a senior Obama advisor, the president made clear he would not back down from his central point - that women employed by Catholic institutions should have the same right to free birth control, with no deductible and no co-pay, as woman employed by any other entity.

"It was hard figuring out the details of how this could work structurally," said John Gehring, who coordinates Catholic outreach for the group Faith in Public Life, a policy advocacy group generally aligned with Democratic policies.

As they struggled to find a solution, the would-be reformers found considerable support within the White House Office of Faith-Based and Neighborhood Partnership, where several staff members suggested they were not happy with the president's original policy. A key point person there: Joshua DuBois, the office head, who knew many of Obama's outside allies from the 2008 campaign and who reports to close Obama confidant Valerie Jarrett.

The faith office "was pressing very hard for a reasonable tweaking of the policy," Gehring said.

Those pushing for compromise also found a friend in Vice President Joe Biden, a fellow Catholic, who had argued from the beginning that religious employers should be exempt from the contraception mandate.

"He understands the Catholic community's views on these issues and is willing to speak up for them when appropriate," said James Salt, executive director of Catholics United, a group with a history of supporting liberal causes.

But though they were getting high-placed signals that a compromise could be worked out, no details emerged. As the days wore on and the political rhetoric grew louder, some Obama allies got discouraged. "The lines in the sand are being drawn sharper and deeper, so I'm not optimistic," Schneck, the political scientist, said earlier this week.

On Friday, Schneck said he realized why he had received so little concrete information about the working compromise. The administration had been so divided in its deliberations about the rule, he said, that "they needed to work this out inside their own walls first," before floating it to key interest groups.

"This was an internecine struggle," he said.

A senior U.S. official said that many of the reports about the internal White House deliberations have been "overdramatized." Officials declined to comment further on internal discussions.

Late Thursday evening, administration officials reached out to Schneck and other involved parties to let them know an announcement was imminent. "There was a tremendous sense of relief," Gehring said.

Before unveiling his compromise Friday morning, Obama called Archbishop Timothy Dolan, president of the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops; Cecile Richards, president of Planned Parenthood Federation of America; and Sister Carol Keehan, president of the Catholic Health Association of the United States.

Richards and Keehan welcomed the announcement. The Conference of Catholic Bishops has been more cautious, releasing a statement calling the new approach promising, but declining to endorse it fully.

The compromise allows religious employers to opt out of providing birth control coverage to employees. But in making that concession, Obama promised those employees that they could get free contraception all the same, courtesy of their health insurance providers.

Obama's Catholic allies said that approach hit all the right notes. "Very practical, very respectful, very common sense," Roemer said.

Sister Campbell wasn't so restrained: "This," she said, "is a glorious day."

(Reporting By Stephanie Simon in Denver. Additional reporting by Caren Bohan in Washington D.C.; Editing by Marilyn W. Thompson and Philip Barbara)


View the original article here

Thứ Năm, 9 tháng 2, 2012

Obama birth-control rule stokes election-year fight

WASHINGTON (Reuters) - The top Republican in the Congress on Wednesday denounced President Barack Obama's new rule on contraceptives as an assault on "religious freedom" and vowed to overturn it, as the White House sought to prevent the issue from becoming an election-year liability.

Fanning a political firestorm, House of Representatives Speaker John Boehner joined an outcry from religious leaders and social conservatives over a requirement that health insurance plans, including those at Catholic hospitals, charities and universities, offer birth control to women.

Seeking to ease a controversy that has roiled the 2012 presidential race, White House spokesman Jay Carney appeared to leave the door open to compromise. He said Obama was sensitive to religious beliefs on contraception and hoped to find a way to implement the rule that can "allay some of the concerns."

But Obama, at a meeting with Senate Democrats, reaffirmed his decision and was "not equivocating," Senator Frank Lautenberg, who attended the closed-door session, told Reuters.

Republicans have seized upon the issue, seeing a chance to paint Obama as anti-religion and put him on the defensive at a time when signs of economic improvement appear to have energized his re-election bid.

The White House, caught off-guard by the fury of the response and now trying to calm objections, accused the Republicans of trying to make "political hay" out of the issue. It said it had begun outside discussions but gave no immediate sign of what, if any, concessions it might make.

"This attack ... on religious freedom in our country cannot stand and will not stand," Boehner vowed in a speech on the floor of his chamber.

The escalating fight centers on a provision in the 2010 healthcare law that requires health insurance to cover basic birth control services for women - even at Catholic charities, hospitals and universities.

Catholic bishops contend the policy infringes on religious liberty because the church does not condone the use of birth control pills or other contraceptives.

Boehner said if the president refuses to rescind the measure, Congress will do so legislatively.

But such a bill would have little chance of getting through a divided Congress. While Boehner may secure backing in the Republican-dominated House, he faces problems in the Senate, which is controlled by Obama's fellow Democrats.

No matter how Congress responds, Obama is in a political bind. A retreat would anger his liberal base, while refusal to budge could alienate some Catholic voters.

SEEKING TO CALM CONCERNS

At the White House, Carney said the administration was "focused on implementation of this rule," but made clear that it had time to try to address opponents' objections.

"There are ways to approach this that would ensure that the rule is implemented so that women have access to these important healthcare services no matter where they work, but also hopefully would allay some of the concerns," Carney said.

Carney pushed back against a New York Times report that Vice President Joe Biden and several other senior Catholic men in the administration cautioned about the political risks and were pitted against women advisers like health secretary Kathleen Sebelius, who argued in favor of the rule.

"I'm not going to get into internal deliberations," Carney told reporters. "Broadly speaking, the reports that line certain people up in some ways on this issue were inaccurate."

The rule has drawn heavy fire from the political right, including Republican presidential candidate Mitt Romney.

Carney took a swipe at Romney on Wednesday, calling him an "odd messenger" to be attacking Obama on the issue. He said it was "ironic" because Romney was criticizing Obama for pursuing a policy that is "virtually identical with the one that was in place when he was governor of Massachusetts."

Romney, speaking to reporters in Atlanta, shot back that Carney "needs to check his history," saying the birth-control provision was already in effect when he took office and that he tried to get it removed.

With the matter threatening to explode into a major election-year fight, Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid has said he and fellow Senate Democrats support the president.

"Some have decided, again, to use women's health for political football," said U.S. Representative Lois Capps, a Democrat.

Backers of Obama's new rule say employees of faith-based groups should have access to birth control services in their health insurance coverage.

The Obama administration said on Tuesday it was willing to work with church-affiliated employers to implement the new policy, which was finalized on January 20 but will not take effect until next year.

During the weekend, clergy from the Catholic Church called for congregations across the country to pressure Obama to back down.

Boehner said, "Americans of every faith and political persuasion have mobilized in objection" to the rule, which he said "constitutes an unambiguous attack on religious freedom."

"This rule would require faith-based employers ... to provide services they consider immoral," he said, including, "sterilization, abortion-inducing drugs and devices, and contraception."

(Additional reporting by David Lawder, Donna Smith and Richard Cowan; editing by Marilyn W. Thompson and Mohammad Zargham)


View the original article here

Thứ Tư, 8 tháng 2, 2012

Obama risks Catholic vote with birth-control mandate

(Reuters) - Dr. Joe Casillas, an obstetrician in Southern California, routinely prescribes birth control for his patients. Though he's a practicing Catholic, he doesn't follow his church's stern warning that contraception is a sin. He believes women should have access.

Yet Casillas was dismayed when the Obama administration recently ruled that religious institutions had to follow the same rules as other employers and offer free contraception as part of health insurance coverage. The idea that the government would force Catholic hospitals to subsidize birth control - or, to avoid the mandate, drop health insurance for their employees - appalled him.

Now Casillas, a registered Democrat who voted for Obama in 2008, says he is not at all sure he can back the president for a second term. "It's given me pause," he said.

Similar shockwaves are reverberating across the country, as Obama's refusal to exempt religious employers from this provision of his health-care law has deeply angered many Catholics - who will make up a crucial, and unpredictable, chunk of the electorate in the November presidential election. About one in four U.S. voters is Catholic and as a group they have swung back and forth between Democrats and Republicans.

In recent days, the administration has said it is willing to work with religious institutions to find ways to cover contraception without violating principles of faith. But no concrete plans for compromise have emerged.

The protest has been led by the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which encouraged parish priests from coast to coast to read aloud fiery letters denouncing the federal policy during Mass. "It is hard not to see this new mandate as a direct attack on Catholic consciences and the freedom of our Catholic institutions," Los Angeles Archbishop Jose H. Gomez wrote in one such letter of protest.

The bishops also urged the faithful to bombard Congress and the White House with complaints. By Tuesday, more than 25,000 people had signed an online petition demanding that the rule be overturned.

FAIRNESS FOR WOMEN

The administration cast the decision as a matter of equity for women. The new federal health care law requires most insurance plans to cover preventive services, such as blood pressure checks and childhood immunizations, without a deductible or co-pay. An outside board of scientists and doctors recommended last summer that contraception be included as a preventive service and the administration agreed.

The mandate does not apply to insurance plans offered by churches and schools that serve and employ primarily people of one faith. Nor does it require any individual physician or pharmacist to provide a service he considers immoral.

But insurance offered by church-affiliated institutions that deal with the public at large, such as hospitals and universities, must cover contraception. The mandate takes effect for most employers August 1; religious employers can apply for a one-year extension.

Jon O'Brien, president of Catholics for Choice, a group that supports access to contraception, said he's heard from hundreds of women employed by Catholic institutions who welcome the new policy - and express anger at the bishops, who they see lobbying to deny them a benefit provided to others under federal law.

"They think it would be a great injustice that they be treated differently from other workers," O'Brien said. "Why is it they should be discriminated against?" Yet many are reluctant to speak out publicly, he said, for fear of angering their employer.

A new poll released Tuesday by the Public Religion Research Institute, a non-partisan research group whose board members include a number of religious leaders who have supported progressive causes, found that a majority of Americans - including 58 percent of Catholics - support a requirement that health insurance plans provide free birth control. A slight majority of Catholic voters, 52 percent, said religiously affiliated colleges and hospitals should also have to provide that benefit.

Without insurance, contraception generally costs $15 to $80 a month, depending on the method and brand. A recent study by the Guttmacher Institute, which supports expanded access to contraception, found that even among women who are employed, one in four says she's found it tough to afford contraception. The study found 18 percent of women who are on the birth-control pill sometimes skip doses or entire months to save money.

"I believe this proposal strikes the appropriate balance between respecting religious freedom and increasing access to important preventive services," Kathleen Sebelius, the secretary of Health and Human Services, said in announcing the policy last month.

The administration also pointed out that 28 states already require insurance plans to cover contraception if they cover other prescription drugs. In most cases, however, religious institutions can get around that requirement through exemptions and loopholes.

The new mandate offers just one loophole: Any employer, including a religious institution, can continue to offer the same health benefits it currently provides, so long as the plan is frozen exactly as is. If the employer or insurer raises costs, tweaks deductibles or changes the benefits in any way - which happens very frequently in most plans - the new rules apply.

Many Catholics - including key Catholic supporters of Obama - said the president gravely miscalculated, on both the moral issue and the political implications.

"These are questions that go to the heart of who we are as a people and as a church," said Douglas Kmiec, a conservative legal scholar who broke from his fellow Republicans to campaign for Obama in 2008 as part of an influential group called Catholics for Obama. "There's no question this will cause complications for Obama."

Obama won the Catholic vote decisively in 2008, on the strength of strong support from Hispanic Catholics. But polls show that a sizeable number of Catholics had already begun to shift allegiances to the Republican Party before this decision. While Catholics as a group still lean left, the Democrats held an edge of just six percentage points among the group last year - down from 16 percentage points in 2008, according to polling by the Pew Research Center.

Political analysts say even before this decision, Obama faced a tough challenge holding on to support from white, working-class Catholics in battleground states such as Pennsylvania, Michigan and Ohio. It was votes from that bloc that helped propel Republican George W. Bush to victory in 2004.

Another crucial group for the president: Hispanic Catholics in swing states such as Nevada, New Mexico and Colorado. Polls show many Latino voters are already upset at Obama for deporting a record number of illegal immigrants during his presidency; for some, this could be the final blow.

"I don't know what to tell you except that everyone's still stunned," said Robert Aguirre, president of the Catholic Association of Latino Leaders, a nonprofit group of business owners and civic leaders.

Obama could take an especially big hit on the issue politically if the Republicans pick Florida Senator Marco Rubio as a vice presidential nominee, political analysts said. Rubio, who is Catholic, has filed a bill to overturn the contraception mandate and could keep the issue alive.

A POLITICAL MISCALCULATION?

Catholics who have worked closely with the White House on various issues said they believe the administration misjudged the response for several reasons.

Polls show that as many as 98 percent of Catholic women in the United States have used birth control, despite the church's teachings.

And Obama received important support from Catholics in his grueling health-care fight; though the bishops opposed his overhaul, other prominent voices in the church supported him on the grounds that extending coverage to more Americans furthered social justice.

So the administration may well have believed that opposition to expanded contraceptive coverage would be muted, said Sister Simone Campbell, executive director of Network, a national Catholic social-justice lobbying group. "You could say they miscalculated," she said.

Indeed, several groups that supported Obama's general health-care goals have issued biting statements opposing the new mandate. "The administration got focused on the substance and missed the higher-level issue of conscience," said Campbell.

For Casillas, the ob/gyn in southern California, that issue of conscience is paramount. It doesn't violate his conscience to prescribe birth control - but he knows other Catholics have a different take. "I want to preserve their ability to maintain their moral compass," he said.

Catholics who continue to back Obama despite their dismay at the contraception mandate say they'll urge voters to consider all of the president's policies, not just this one ruling.

That tactic worked in 2008, when Catholics for Obama put out radio ads and booklets arguing that Obama's policies on aiding the poor and ending the wars in Afghanistan and Iraq were in line with Catholic social justice teachings - and made him a moral choice for president, despite his support for legal abortion.

The president seemed to be laying the groundwork for a repeat of that campaign when he spoke at the National Prayer Breakfast last week. He told the crowd of religious leaders that many of his policies, including his call for the wealthy to pay more in taxes, sprang from Biblical teaching. "For me as a Christian," Obama said, the proposed tax hike "coincides with Jesus's teaching that 'for unto whom much is given, much shall be required.'"

It's unclear how well that tactic will play in this election, after the latest furor. "The Obama campaign went out of its way in 2008 to court Catholics," said Stephen Schneck, a political scientist at the Catholic University of America who has advised the president on outreach. "This could be messing all that up."

(Reporting By Stephanie Simon in Denver; Additional reporting by Lily Kuo in Washington; Editing by Claudia Parsons)


View the original article here